Where To Buy British Candy In New York Apr 2026

This is arguably the most famous British grocery in the city. Established in 1985, it’s a "piece of home" for expats, stocking classics like Maltesers , Smarties , Turkish Delight , and After Eight mints . They also have a massive selection of British biscuits and freshly baked goods like pork pies. Economy Candy Candy store ClosedLower East Side

If you're hunting for a "finger of fudge" or proper UK Cadbury that hasn't been tweaked for American palates, New York City has a few legendary spots where you can find authentic British sweets. Top Shops for British Candy in NYC Myers of Keswick ClosedGreenwich Village where to buy british candy in new york

This celebrated British chocolatier recently opened its first NYC location on the Upper East Side, offering high-quality UK-style chocolate truffles and bars. Harry Potter Shop New York ClosedFlatiron District This is arguably the most famous British grocery in the city

A floor-to-ceiling candy paradise since 1937. While they carry everything, they have a dedicated international section where you can often find British staples at more "economical" prices than specialty boutiques. Carry On Tea & Sympathy ClosedGreenwich Village Economy Candy Candy store ClosedLower East Side If

Located in the "Little Britain" corner of the West Village, this shop is packed with imported chocolates, Rowntree's fruit pastilles , and nostalgia-inducing holiday boxes. It’s a great stop if you’re also looking for British cordials or teas. Big Cheers (UK Groceries) Gourmet grocery store ClosedLower East Side

While specifically themed, the shop stocks Wizarding World-inspired British treats like Bertie Bott's Every Flavour Beans . Quick Comparison of Classics