Kate opens up to Joe about her past and her father’s influence, deepening their emotional connection even as Joe’s mental state becomes more precarious.

Back in London, Joe's student Nadia begins to piece together the truth about her professor, becoming one of the first characters to see through Joe's "Jonathan Moore" persona. Cast & Characters Penn Badgley as Joe Goldberg (Jonathan Moore) Ed Speleers as Rhys Montrose Charlotte Ritchie as Kate Galvin Amy-Leigh Hickman as Nadia Farran Where to Watch

This episode is often cited by fans as the moment the season shifts from a "Whodunit" mystery into a psychological thriller. Critics praised performance as Joe's internal logic starts to fail him, creating a sense of dread that carries into the season finale.

In Season 4, Episode 7, the "Eat the Rich" killer's identity has been revealed to the audience, but Joe is struggling to reconcile his own actions with his perceived identity. The episode focuses on Joe’s psychological breakdown as he attempts to "stop" Rhys Montrose, while simultaneously dealing with the escalating suspicions of those around him, particularly Roald and Kate.

Joe remains fixated on Rhys Montrose as his ultimate antagonist. He believes Rhys is blackmailing him and forcing him to commit further acts of violence.