In the episode " Say It Ain't So, Spencer ," Spencer Carlin struggles with her growing feelings for Ashley and attempts to suppress them by going on a date with Aiden. This decision leaves Ashley feeling betrayed, leading her to spiral and hook up with an old flame named Paige. Episode Overview Original Air Date : January 27, 2006.

: By the end of the episode, Spencer realizes she cannot run from her feelings and apologizes to Ashley, staying the night to care for her.

: Clay faces obstacles and emotional distress while searching for his birth mother, leading him to feel disconnected from his family and heritage.

: Paula and Arthur begin couples counseling to address their mounting marital issues.